Home
NRL

Why Michael Maguire Deserves More Respect Than He’s Getting

Joel Johnston

Editor

Last updated: Fri 27 Mar 2026 07:41

Joel Johnston 27 Mar 2026

Share this article

Michael Maguire's recent achievements include a premiership win and State of Origin success.
Media narratives overshadow his achievements despite his solid coaching record.
Broncos need patience; Maguire's record deserves more respect and evaluation over time.

Head Coach Michael Maguire of the Broncos. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Why Michael Maguire Deserves More Respect Than He’s Getting

It does not take long in rugby league for the narrative to turn.

Six months ago, Michael Maguire was a premiership-winning coach. Now, depending on which headline you read, you would think the Brisbane Broncos are a club in serious trouble. That shift in perception has come quickly, and when you step back from it, it does not quite line up with reality.

Because when you strip away the noise, Maguire’s recent record still stacks up with just about anyone in the game.

The Results Still Stack Up

Over the past few years, he has won a premiership, delivered a State of Origin series win and had success on the international stage. There are not many active coaches who can point to that kind of run, particularly across multiple levels of the game. And yet, the conversation around him right now feels like it is building pressure rather than recognising what has already been achieved.

That disconnect says more about how the game is being talked about than what is actually happening on the field.

Part of that comes down to the club he is coaching. The Broncos are not just another NRL side. They are the biggest club in the competition, which means everything around them is louder, bigger and more heavily scrutinised. A coaching disagreement or an assistant moving on is not unusual in the NRL, but at Brisbane it quickly becomes a major talking point.

That is the environment Maguire is operating in, and it naturally amplifies any hint of instability.

Coaching Realities vs Public Perception

It is also worth remembering that coaching at this level is rarely clean or straightforward. Assistant coaches and head coaches will not always agree on tactics or direction, and in many cases that tension is part of what drives high performance. When those disagreements stay internal, they are just part of the job. When they become public, they tend to get framed as dysfunction, even when the reality is far more nuanced as we have seen with the depature of Assistant Coach Ben Te'o this week.

In Maguire’s case, the more important question is not whether there has been friction behind the scenes, but whether the system he has built is still capable of producing results. Based on what we have seen recently, there is very little to suggest that it is not.

The bigger issue sits around how narratives are formed in rugby league. It is a game built on strong personalities, and a lot of the coverage comes from people who have deep connections to clubs, players and coaches. That is part of what makes the sport engaging, but it also means opinions are rarely formed in a vacuum.

Once a storyline takes hold, it can gather momentum quickly, regardless of whether the underlying results support it.

The Narrative Is Moving Faster Than Reality

Right now, the idea that Maguire is under pressure feels like one of those storylines. It has built quickly, it is being repeated often, and it risks overshadowing the fact that he is coming off one of the most successful periods of any coach in the competition.

For the Broncos, the path forward is actually quite simple. They have a proven coach with a track record of success and a roster capable of competing at the top end of the ladder. That combination should allow for some patience, particularly this early in a season.

Coaches are ultimately judged on results, and Maguire has earned the right to be assessed over a meaningful period, not just a handful of weeks and a few headlines.

The next few months will shape how this season is viewed, but the broader point remains the same. Michael Maguire has already shown he can build a winning team, and until that changes, his record should carry more weight than the noise around him.