Northerly, Cosmic Crusader and the Heavy Burden of Railway Stakes History
Cosmic Crusader returns to contest the Railway Stakes, carrying 61kg—the highest weight since Northerly’s 2001 attempt. Only two horses, Tudor Mak and Luckygray, have managed to win the Railway Stakes twice, underlining the challenge Cosmic Crusader faces. He will meet previous winners Western Empire, Watch Me Rock, and Bustler, all seeking a second triumph. Despite a favourable draw and strong Group 1 credentials, the narrow weight spread and historical precedent make a repeat win a significant challenge for Cosmic Crusader in this year’s field.
- Cosmic Crusader faces a daunting 61kg Railway Stakes challenge, the heaviest impost since Northerly in 2001
- Northerly's failed title defence under 61.5kg provides a fascinating comparison with this year's Cox Plate winner
- The two champions' careers, achievements and heavyweight assignments highlight the enduring difficulty of winning the Railway Stakes
Northerly wins the 2002 Cox Plate at Moonee Valley, having faced a monumental weight challenge in the previous year's Railway Stakes. (Getty)
There is that one moment when a champion bursts onto the scene, that one special win that sticks in the memory.
Such a race was the 2000 Group 1 Railway Stakes.
The race boasts a long history, first run on the same day as the inaugural Perth Cup in 1887.
Since then, it has undergone changes in distance and scheduling, but it has remained true to its purpose as a test of the best locals against the interstate raiders.
Its honour roll features a number of stars, with Aquanita and Better Loosen Up among the standouts.
And a horse called Northerly.
A winner of the Listed Aquanita Stakes at just his second start, the Fred Kersley-trained gelding was spelled before beginning his second campaign with a fourth at Ascot.
He then hit form, winning a Class 6 at the same track before claiming the Group 3 R.J. Peters Stakes.
His victory in the latter was so authoritative that Northerly was well fancied come Railway day, although he was still not favourite. That honour went to Umrum on the back of outstanding form in Melbourne and Perth.
Northerly had only recently turned four, and Group 1 company represented a significant step for a still-inexperienced horse. He had also drawn awkwardly in barrier 12 of the 15 runners.
From that gate, under the guidance of Danny Miller, Northerly did not enjoy the easiest of runs and was already challenging the leaders well before the turn.
A Definitive Moment
Taking the lead into the straight, he kicked clear and was never in any danger of defeat. Everyone watching knew this was a definitive moment, the start of something special.
Two starts later, Northerly was in Melbourne, bolting in with the Group 2 Carlyon Cup before winning the Group 1 Australian Cup with ease just two starts after that.
In the spring, he added another three elite-level victories to his record, including the first of his two Group 1 W.S. Cox Plates.
It was after that race in 2001 that Northerly headed home to again contest the Railway Stakes. In the space of a year, his form had improved to such an extent that he was asked to carry 10.5kg more than he had when successful in 2000.
61.5kg.
In the race's long history, only two horses have won the Railway Stakes twice: Tudor Mak in 1966 and 1967, and Luckygray in 2011 and 2013. Group 1 handicaps are notoriously difficult races in which to repeat success.
Tudor Mak carried 49kg for his first Railway victory and 61kg for his second. Luckygray carried 53kg and 58kg respectively.
Northerly had a bit of history to contend with and was sent out as the 5/4 favourite, a generous quote considering his form.
But the test proved too much for the gallant gelding, who faded in the run home as another high-class local, Old Comrade, claimed victory.
Runner-up to Northerly the previous year, Old Comrade would go on to win the following year's Group 1 Australian Cup, with Northerly finishing second.
Old Comrade carried 53.5kg in the Railway, 8kg less than Northerly. The second-highest weighted runner had just 54kg, creating one of the biggest gaps between the top two weights in Australian racing history.
Weight Stopped Phar Lap
The 1931 Melbourne Cup was a similar story, with an unplaced Phar Lap carrying 8.5kg more than his nearest rival.
Fast forward to 2026, and another W.S. Cox Plate winner has returned to Western Australia to contest the Railway Stakes: Cosmic Crusader.
Unlike Northerly, he has not previously contested a Railway, with Saturday's race marking his first attempt at his hometown feature.
But he has a similar weight to carry: 61kg.
It is the most weight allocated to a runner in the Railway Stakes since Northerly.
Handicap racing has changed, however, and the spread of weights is no longer as wide. In 2001, Northerly's topweight of 61.5kg contrasted with five horses carrying just 51kg.
This year, 54kg is the minimum, with all but four runners allotted that weight.
Cosmic Crusader is being asked to concede 4kg to the next horse in the weights, Western Empire.
That galloper is attempting to achieve what Northerly could not by winning a second Railway Stakes, while also chasing a slice of history.
Should he succeed, he would become the first horse since the introduction of the pattern system to win the same Group 1 contest five years apart.
Another two runners are also attempting to claim the race for a second time, with last year's winner Watch Me Rock again taking his place, rising just 1.5kg in the weights.
Bustler, meanwhile, has 1kg more than the 53kg he carried to victory in 2023.
Career Comparisons
Northerly's 2001 rider, Damien Oliver, never won a Railway Stakes, as much as he wanted to!
Cosmic Crusader's jockey, William Pike, has steered home six winners of the race since 2014.
Cosmic Crusader (barrier six) has a more favourable draw than Northerly, who drew wide in both of his Railway appearances.
He faces three Group 1-winning rivals, whereas heading into the 2001 Railway Stakes, only Northerly and Old Comrade had previously enjoyed success at that level.
Northerly went straight from the Cox Plate to the Railway, while Cosmic Crusader has had a run in between, losing no admirers with his game Group 1 Champions Stakes second to Cox Plate runner-up Birdman.
Looking further back at their respective careers, Northerly did not make his debut until March of his three-year-old season, by which stage Cosmic Crusader had already raced seven times.
Northerly was fourth-up when winning the Railway and seventh-up when unplaced the following year. Cosmic Crusader will be having his ninth run of the campaign on Saturday.
Cosmic Crusader has won 12 of his 25 starts, while Northerly had recorded 15 victories at the same stage of his career.
Northerly's wins came over distances ranging from 1300m to 2400m, while Cosmic Crusader has been successful between 1200m and 2040m.
Northerly started favourite on 23 occasions, winning 11 times. Cosmic Crusader has won six of his 16 starts as favourite.
Should Cosmic Crusader win on Saturday, he will share three feature race victories with Northerly, including the Cox Plate and Turnbull Stakes.
The W.S. Cox Plate
In winning this year's Cox Plate, Cosmic Crusader defeated 11 rivals who had collectively won 20 Group 1 races.
In the same race in 2001, Northerly had just seven rivals to beat, but those horses had collectively won 22 Group 1 races, nine of them courtesy of Sunline.
In 2002, Northerly beat eight rivals whose combined Group 1 tally stood at 24, with Sunline responsible for 13 of those victories.
These are all facts and figures, but at the end of the day, they do not really tell us which horse was the better of the two. Champions from different eras are particularly difficult to compare.
Bart Cummings has been credited with the line, "Champions should never be compared, only admired."
But it is doubtful that many would rank Cosmic Crusader, as wonderful a horse as he is, above Northerly, even should he accomplish on Saturday what that champion could not.
Betting offers
Upcoming Events
19 November 2026
- Mornington - November 19 -
- Horse Racing
- Albury - November 19 -
- Horse Racing
- Illawarra Hawks vs Adelaide 36ers -
- Basketball
- Ben Shelton vs Rafael Jodar -
- Tennis
- Alexander Zverev vs Arthur Fils -
- Tennis
20 November 2026
- Grafton - November 20 -
- Horse Racing
- Pakenham- November 20 -
- Horse Racing
- Launceston - November 20 -
- Horse Racing
- Cairns Taipans vs Perth Wildcats -
- Basketball
- Western Sydney Wanderers v Adelaide United -
- Soccer
- Gold Coast - November 20 -
- Horse Racing
21 November 2026
- Auckland FC v Melbourne Victory -
- Soccer
- Railway Stakes -
- Horse Racing
- Central Coast Mariners v Perth Glory -
- Soccer
- Brisbane Roar v Sydney FC -
- Soccer
Load More
